The English Teacher's Association (ETA) of NSW has opposed the move to strengthen the teaching of Australian literature in schools.
The ETA objects to ‘the selective nomination of some types of text as this implies hierarchies in generic form and medium rather than in the quality of the texts themselves', as reported in the Australian.
The ruling was based on a survey of ETA members in which 43 out of 1800 replied. The ETA is also quoted as saying that restricting the definition of literature to the print medium is ‘imprudent, reductive, short-sighted and, most importantly, undermines the integrity of current English syllabuses'.
The ETA argues that ‘Any definition of 'Australian' needs to see Australia in a global context, and to take account of indigenous and multicultural perspectives'.
However, Jeremy Fisher, executive director of the Australian Society of Authors (ASA) says the ETA's published comments are ‘a total insult to Australian authors and their achievements'.
Fisher told the Australian in response that a trial conducted by the ASA and the NSW and Federal Departments of Education and Training in fact proved that teaching Australian literature in schools ‘increases both literacy levels and the engagement of students with narrative forms'. He encourages Australian authors to respond to the Australian's article.
How can the majority?? view of 43 out of a membership of 1800 of ETA of NSW be taken as an authorative statement of ETA Policy? What a hide to publish this view!
The wisest thing for almost the entire membership of ETA is to move for the deregistration of these 22 odd members for falsly claiming such authority and bringing ETA into conflict with plain common sense and the plain results of recent full review that show the fall in literacy level and reading proficiency is the lowest for decades.
This inane guff has exposed all genuine English teachers to ridicule at a time when school curriculums throughout Australia are under severe question because of bad results.
Perhaps these 22 to 43 English teachers have influenced this?
The ability to read and understand is the fulcrum of learning, and also the ability to be authors. Are these 22-43 so-called teachers implying that Australian Authors (thankfully educated prior to these twits arriving) now proclaiming that we are illiterate?
This is discraceful and insulting but above all a betrayal of today's youth and of the honourable profession they claim to represent.
SHAME on them.
John Peach
What's Hot in the Media 1st December 2008 This week's Most Mentioned books were largely Australian in theme with The Best Australian Stories 2008, Tie Me Kangaroo down, Sport and Churchill and Australia all making the top 10.1 December, 2008
Bestsellers this week It's that time of year again when that hefty tome, the Guinness World Records (2009) boldly makes its first appearance on top of the charts.27 November, 2008
Ten Days on the Island program launched The program for Tasmanian arts festival Ten Days on the Island, which runs from 27 March to 5 April, was launched yesterday.27 November, 2008
The Memory Room' wins Waverley award Christopher Koch has been awarded the 2008 CAL Waverley Library Award for Literature (‘The Nib') for his novel The Memory Room (Vintage).27 November, 2008
Bestsellers this week A familiar street name (to Melbournians at any rate) and now book is atop the Highest New Entries chart this week--Lygon St by Michael Harden.20 November, 2008
YABBA winners announced The YABBAs (Young Australian Best Book Award) were announced this week in Victoria.20 November, 2008
Pattrick wins Mansfield Prize The 2009 New Zealand Post Mansfield Prize has gone to Jenny Pattrick.20 November, 2008
Comments
1 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.
How can the majority?? view of 43 out of a membership of 1800 of ETA of NSW be taken as an authorative statement of ETA Policy? What a hide to publish this view! The wisest thing for almost the entire membership of ETA is to move for the deregistration of these 22 odd members for falsly claiming such authority and bringing ETA into conflict with plain common sense and the plain results of recent full review that show the fall in literacy level and reading proficiency is the lowest for decades. This inane guff has exposed all genuine English teachers to ridicule at a time when school curriculums throughout Australia are under severe question because of bad results. Perhaps these 22 to 43 English teachers have influenced this? The ability to read and understand is the fulcrum of learning, and also the ability to be authors. Are these 22-43 so-called teachers implying that Australian Authors (thankfully educated prior to these twits arriving) now proclaiming that we are illiterate? This is discraceful and insulting but above all a betrayal of today's youth and of the honourable profession they claim to represent. SHAME on them. John Peach
Add a Comment
Please be civil.