HarperCollins has responded to claims that it has published material offensive to the Australian Indigenous community. The publisher ‘apologises unreservedly' and ‘will replace this item when the book is reprinted as clearly we had no intention to offend', reported The Australian.
The Daring Book for Girls, which is published next month, features a section teaching girls to play the didgeridoo. Leading Indigenous educator Mark Rose has called for the book to be destroyed, reported Simon Lauder on ABC Local Radio. ‘In our times there are men's business and women's business, and the didgeridoo is definitely a men's business ceremonial tool', said Rose.
Rose, who is general manager of the Victorian Education Association, said it was an ‘extreme mistake' and part of ‘a general ignorance that mainstream Australia has about Aboriginal culture'.
I mean no offence to the aboriginal community, but I think in our modern times the didgeridoo has actually taken the step from 'sacred aboriginal mens business' to actual musical instrument.
The book isnt telling girls to learn the didgeridoo and perform in a sacred ceremony. Its telling them to learn it as a musical instrument. So how is it different from learning the bagpipes which also have specific ceremonial uses?
And does this mean that the sale of the didgeridoo musical instrument now needs to be restricted to men only?
Are they now going to be attacking buskers in the Brisbane mall who are playing the didgeridoo? Or is that acceptable because it is a man playing it (even though its obviously being used to make money and not for ceremonial uses).
The Aboriginal belief behind the men only business reaches to the inclusion that should a woman play this instrument, they will lose their ability to have children.
I think you have made some very valid points Leisa, and there are many more that could be made in a similar vein. I would add that it is shameful that a man in such a position as Mr Rose should be wasting precious energy on looking backwards to what was, and creating a storm in a teacup over a musical instrument instead of doing a proper job of looking forward and putting some real energy and thought, and more concern into addressing the woeful status, in every sense of the word of todays aboriginal woman. I say Harper Collins perhaps acknowledge the role of the didgeridoo but delete it... no way!
Bestsellers this week It's great to see a book from a relatively small publisher get top spot in the charts.2 July, 2009
Wilderness Society Environment Award for Children's Literature 2009 announced True Green Kids: 100 Things You Can Do to Save the Planet (Kim McKay and Jenny Bonnin, ABC Books) and Tuart Dwellers (Jan Ramage, illus. Ellen Hickman, WA Dept of Environment and Conservation) have been announced as joint winners of the 2009 Wilderness Society Environment Award for Children's Literature.2 July, 2009
What's Hot in the Media 30th June 2009 In the face of work pressure and family commitments, sleep is usually the first aspect of adult life to suffer.30 June, 2009
Bestsellers this week What is it about people these days and their obsession with vampires?24 June, 2009
Beattie to film John Marsden's 'Tomorrow' series Stuart Beattie, co-writer of the epic Australia, will make his directorial debut with John Marsden’s Tomorrow, When the War Began, first published by Pan in 1994 and aimed at young adults.24 June, 2009
The Slap' wins booksellers' choice award Christos Tsiolkas was announced on Monday night as the winner of the Nielsen BookData 2009 Booksellers' Choice Award for his multiple prize-winning novel The Slap (A&U).24 June, 2009
2009 ABIA Awards announced The 2009 Australian Book Industry Awards (ABIAs) were presented last night, Tuesday 23 June, at a gala event at Sydney's Sofitel, hosted by Tara Moss.24 June, 2009
What's Hot in the Media 23rd June 2009 News of Tim Winton's Miles Franklin Award win for his novel Breath was strewn all over Australia's book pages and beyond at the weekend.23 June, 2009
Victorian Writers' Centre workshops Writing Romance with Anne Gracie Short Course: Romance is character-driven genre fiction and accounts for a huge chunk of the international fiction market, which is why romance writers can earn a living from their writing.17 June, 2009
Comments
3 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.
I mean no offence to the aboriginal community, but I think in our modern times the didgeridoo has actually taken the step from 'sacred aboriginal mens business' to actual musical instrument.
The book isnt telling girls to learn the didgeridoo and perform in a sacred ceremony. Its telling them to learn it as a musical instrument. So how is it different from learning the bagpipes which also have specific ceremonial uses? And does this mean that the sale of the didgeridoo musical instrument now needs to be restricted to men only?
Are they now going to be attacking buskers in the Brisbane mall who are playing the didgeridoo? Or is that acceptable because it is a man playing it (even though its obviously being used to make money and not for ceremonial uses).
The Aboriginal belief behind the men only business reaches to the inclusion that should a woman play this instrument, they will lose their ability to have children.
I think you have made some very valid points Leisa, and there are many more that could be made in a similar vein. I would add that it is shameful that a man in such a position as Mr Rose should be wasting precious energy on looking backwards to what was, and creating a storm in a teacup over a musical instrument instead of doing a proper job of looking forward and putting some real energy and thought, and more concern into addressing the woeful status, in every sense of the word of todays aboriginal woman. I say Harper Collins perhaps acknowledge the role of the didgeridoo but delete it... no way!
Add a Comment
Please be civil.