The Persian Blanket by Tim Chappell and Janine Milek
This is the remarkable life story of Janine Milek. Born in Poland, she and her family were sent by the Russians to Siberia, where they were forced to work in labour camps.
This is the remarkable life story of Janine Milek. Born in Poland, she and her family were sent by the Russians to Siberia, where they were forced to work in labour camps. On their release they became refugees, spending time in Uzbekistan, Persia and Africa. Throughout these painful years of homelessness, starvation and hard work, Janine’s relatives died or were dispersed, leaving her alone for her migration to Western Australia in 1950. She began a new life working as a hospital cleaner and saving for her long-held dream of buying her own house. She befriended the Chappell family, including 18-month-old Tim, who as an adult began to tape Janine’s oral history. He has rewritten her stories to form this account, retaining the flavour of his friend’s language. The Persian Blanket is a readable but ultimately disappointing book, as the language and storytelling do not do justice to the material. While Janine’s experiences are extraordinary, this unsophisticated account does little to evoke them for the reader and makes no attempt to put them in any historical context. This is an interesting life story rather than a powerful memoir. Without the detail that might have brought her stories to life, this is a strangely unmoving book.
I'm a Polish woman in my late twenties and I have to disagree with the above review. While native English readers may find the language in the book just readable and not powerful enough, Polish person knows exactly what Janine is trying to say using these simple words. Despite knowing last century's historical facts (as any Polish child would) I haven't realized how strongly they affected ordinary people's lives. I knew that some of Polish civilians ended up in Argentina, Canada and Australia after the II WW. How it happened? It never even occurred to me. After reading Janine Milek's life story it become clear how much pain she had to go through to pursue her Dream of Freedom. Dream of Freedom that predominated lives of so many. Freedom, that my generation takes for granted. Shouldn't we feel truly lucky and privileged for having it?
For me, that is moving...
Burnt Shadows by Kamila Shamsie Later, the one who survives will remember that day as grey, but on the morning of 9 August itself both the man from Berlin, Konrad Weiss, and the schoolteacher, Hiroko Tanaka, step out of their houses and notice the perfect blueness of the sky.14 April, 2009
Nocturnes by Kazuo Ishiguro Nocturne ( definition): A pensive, melancholy musical composition; a night piece.14 April, 2009
The Reader Why did you not unlock the doors?3 April, 2009
The Darwin Poems by Emily Ballou The Darwin Poems is a poetic portrait of Charles Darwin, consisting of 73 individually stunning poems.26 March, 2009
Witches Incorporated by K E Mills Witches Incorporated is the second book in the Rogue Agent fantasy series by K E Mills, a pseudonym of Sydney-based bestselling speculative fiction writer Karen Miller.23 March, 2009
Versace Sisters by Cate Kendall Cate Kendall’s Versace Sisters is the follow-up to the successful Gucci Mamas.23 March, 2009
Reunion by Andrea Goldsmith A close-knit group of friends from university have been apart for 20 years, living in different corners of the world, building careers and reputations.23 March, 2009
The Marriage Club by Kate Legge Kate Legge’s second novel is an absorbing examination of the nature of marriage, the choices people make and what we show our friends.23 March, 2009
Comments
1 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.
I'm a Polish woman in my late twenties and I have to disagree with the above review. While native English readers may find the language in the book just readable and not powerful enough, Polish person knows exactly what Janine is trying to say using these simple words. Despite knowing last century's historical facts (as any Polish child would) I haven't realized how strongly they affected ordinary people's lives. I knew that some of Polish civilians ended up in Argentina, Canada and Australia after the II WW. How it happened? It never even occurred to me. After reading Janine Milek's life story it become clear how much pain she had to go through to pursue her Dream of Freedom. Dream of Freedom that predominated lives of so many. Freedom, that my generation takes for granted. Shouldn't we feel truly lucky and privileged for having it? For me, that is moving...
Add a Comment
Please be civil.