The Cruel Legacy: The HMAS Voyager Tragedy by Tom Frame
Australia’s greatest peacetime naval disaster occurred in February 1964 when the destroyer HMAS Voyager collided with the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne. Voyager was sunk with the loss of 82 officers and men.
Published 2 March, 2005
The Cruel Legacy: The HMAS Voyager Tragedy (Tom Frame, Allen & Unwin, $29.95 pb, ISBN 1741144213, February) HHH
Australia’s greatest peacetime naval disaster occurred in February 1964 when the destroyer HMAS Voyager collided with the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne. Voyager was sunk with the loss of 82 officers and men. A subsequent Royal Commission found the Voyager’s captain (who died in the accident) to be at fault, but also ascribed some responsibility to Captain Robertson of HMAS Melbourne. Following regular challenges to the Commission’s findings a second Commission varied the conclusions of the original investigation, absolving Robertson of any responsibility. Tom Frame has described the accident and the investigations which followed in his earlier book Where Fate Calls: The HMAS Voyager Tragedy. In this second book Tom Frame has taken the opportunity to include amendments and additions where new information has become available. He now looks critically at the two Royal Commissions, their appropriateness and the reasons why they failed to uncover the truth about the collision. He describes the political intrigues and cover-ups, and the antagonism between the navy and the federal government over the inquiry and how it would be run. He draws conclusions about the accident and its consequences for both the navy and the survivors of the collision. An essential read for all those still concerned about the circumstances surrounding this tragic accident.
Chris Harrington is co-owner of Melbourne’s Books in Print
A Rose for the Anzac Boys by Jackie FrenchJackie French believes that good, historical writing really needs to come from source documents: things written at the time that give the feeling of the world as it was then, not just the facts. 16 March, 2008
ANZAC Day reads for 2008Anzac Day is fast approaching. Anzac: An Illustrated History 1914-1918 by Richard Pelvin will be released in paperback this year to coincide with the day (Hardie Grant). 13 March, 2008
Tales from the frontPersonal accounts, biographies, histories and even guide books—Australia’s military history is the subject of a whole army of books hitting the shelves this month. 5 October, 2006
The Wreck of the Batavia and Prosper by Simon LeysThe story of the wreck of the Batavia has been the inspiration for many works of fiction, nonfiction and film. Leys’ essay on the wreck begins with a curious introduction. He explains a long-held desire to write the tale of the Batavia; nervously reading all the other publications on the topic; and concluding none of them hit the mark. 11 December, 2005
Beyond Belief by Roger CrossThe authors of this book, Roger Cross, a senior fellow at Melbourne University, and Avon Hudson, a campaigner for victims of British atomic tests in Australia, argue that because Australia was such an eagerly subservient ally, it was kept in the dark about the real extent of the 12 atomic tests carried out at Maralinga in the years 1952–1957, and the minor trials that continued until 1962. 20 June, 2005
An Australian connection: Robert Ryan's new book, After MidnightRobert Ryan is a pretty big deal sales-wise in the UK, where his books are regular features of the Top 10 lists. Here in Australia, his fans are not quite so legion, but that may all be set to change with the Australian connection in his latest novel, After Midnight, he told Eliza Metcalfe. 13 May, 2005
Darkness in Paris by Peter FergusonIn May 1940 Germany invaded France and within six weeks had triumphantly seized control of Paris. The Allies' complacency was replaced with a sense of helplessness as they were defeated by a new kind of dynamic warfare. 11 May, 2005
Hellfire: Australia, Japan and the Prisoners of War by Cameron ForbesHellfire traces the experiences of the Australian, British and Allied prisoners of war under Japanese occupation during World War II. The book analyses the cultural differences, dating from the 19th century, which underpinned the attitudes of the politicians and the military on both sides of the conflict. 11 April, 2005
Animal Heroes by Anthony HillFollowing on from the success of historical narratives like Soldier Boy and Young Digger that explore untold stories from Australia’s fighting past, Anthony Hill’s Animal Heroes collates and presents the important role animals have played in conflicts from the World War I to the present day. Hill’s text clearly conveys the love and admiration these animals were afforded by their handlers, comrades or adopted owners. Whether they were an intuitive kitten smuggled aboard HMAS Perth, a Doberman who defected for a tin of bully beef, or one of the 11 tracking dogs who served so valiantly in Vietnam, each animal’s story is lovingly retold through surviving memory of family members, or official documents. 20 March, 2005
Well Done, Those Men by Barry HeardBarry Heard’s quiet life on a remote Victorian farm was interrupted by ‘a very official letter in a brown envelope’ that turned up one day in 1964. He had been called up for National Service, or ‘Nasho’. A lucky brush with German measles kept him out of the army the first time around, but by February 1966 21-year-old Heard was off to the Puckapunyal army base. For a naïve country boy the army training was an adventure full of blokey bonhomie, but one that suddenly became very serious once he was stationed with a regular regiment, the 7RAR, that was about to be deployed in Vietnam. 20 March, 2005
|
|
|
Add a Comment
Please be civil.