Anyone familiar with the song 'Click go the Shears' will be aware of the role of shearers as a significant part of our national identity. Beaten By a Blow provides an insight into Dennis McIntosh’s career progression as a shearer. From his lowly start as a roustabout; cleaning the woolsheds and removing the shorn fleeces; through to a qualified shearer, sought after to be part of the shearing team. This memoir covers a wide range of topics, including documentation of the union struggle against the Fraser government and New Zealand import shearers in the late 70s and early 80s. It also covers Mcintosh’s young family and his constant struggle to make ends meet. The book is very engaging to begin, but the later chapters feel rushed and the ending is quite abrupt. There is a lot of attention paid at every point to the number of sheep every character has shorn. This is overdone and distracts from the story at times. Certainly not a happy read, this is a true 'Aussie battler' story. Written for a male audience, this larrikin memoir tells a tale of loyalty and mateship, but ever present is the underlying struggle to get by.
Tristan Blattman is special sales manager for UNSW Bookshop
Tags:
dennis mcIntosh
Riding the Black Cockatoo by John DanalisReconciliation is a catchcry often featured in the media, but Riding the Black Cockatoo has brought new life into a thorny issue.
17 June, 2009
The House of Wisdom by Jonathan LyonsBaghdad: 'The Round City', 'The City of Peace'. This doesn't sound much like the city we hear of today.
4 April, 2009
In Someone Else's Shoes by Joseph AssafOur diversity has the potential to offer greatness, but it also presents opportunities for disaster. 30 March, 2009
Wired Brown Land: Telstra’s Battle for Broadband by Paul FletcherPicture the scene at Optus headquarters in mid-2008 with the government trying to get the National Broadband Network off the ground, monopoly provider Telstra looks like the obvious choice.
24 March, 2009
Pro Hart: The Pro Hart Pocket Companion by Paul LonerganWith the introduction by Raylee Hart, this easyto- carry, compact pocket companion showcases a selection—on a smaller scale—of the prodigious work of the late Pro Hart.
24 March, 2009
My Kid is Back: Empowering Parents to Beat Anorexia Nervosa by June Alexander & Daniel le GrangeMy Kid Is Back gives voice to 10 Australian families whose children have suffered anorexia. Interviewed by journalist June Alexander, they talk frankly about the onset of the disease, their sometimeslengthy struggle to find effective help, and their relief at discovering the Maudsley Approach of family-based treatment.
24 March, 2009
Hey Mum, What’s a Half-Caste? by Lorraine McGee-SippelLorraine McGee-Sippel always felt like an outsider but never knew why.
23 March, 2009
Gallipoli: The End of the Myth by Robin PriorGallipoli: The End of the Myth is an in-depth and intense look at the minutiae of the Gallipoli campaign.
23 March, 2009
Comments
4 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.
OK, I just finished it and I really did love it. Throughout the book you're not wanting to put it down and it really did open my eyes a little. Why do I complain when things could be so much worse. It shows what some peoples work ethic can actually be. My only complaint, how it ended. 2 points; 1- left me hanging a little, I need to hear more of the family ans 2 - the fact that it ended at all.
Great Book ! Couldn't put it down. Annoyed about the ending. Hope Dennis is working on a sequel. It would be a bloody shame if he is not. Why shoot his dog???
Great read, brought back the good and bad memories of my shearing days in same era. Also hope Dennis is going to keep writing as the story wasn't finished. With the move to wide combs,pay rates getting better and his personal life saga I'm sure he can write on.
I didn't find the last chapters rushed, nor the tally figures distracting - to me, these accentuated the driving determination of Dennis McIntosh to keep grinding away until he could shear 100 - then 200 a day; and accentuated the fiercely competitive nature of shearing, something I'd been previously unaware of.
Nor did I think it was a book 'written for a male audience'. In fact I'd especially recommend this book to any woman who wants to understand better, the stereotypical boy who physically works hard but hates school, and is written off as not very smart by teachers; though they're actually clever and very driven to reach goals, when they find their niche. There are a lot of mothers, sisters and especially (female) teachers that may benefit from reading this book! Like real life, it doesn't have a neat ending; and like the others that I am itching to hear what happened next, and how Dennis is getting along these days. I hope life is treating him better. Unfortunately the significance of this book will be lost on the average Australian. It's not just well read and a good yarn, it is a sensitive account of an aspect of rural culture that has never been attended to like this before.
Add a Comment
Please be civil.