1300 36 33 32

A selection of important writings which together suggest that legal philosophy is the nerve of legal reasoning.

Buy Matter of Principle book by Ronald M. Dworkin from Australia's Online Bookstore, Boomerang Books.

Book Details

ISBN: 9780198255741
ISBN-10: 0198255748
Format: Paperback
(234mm x 157mm x 23mm)
Pages: 436
Imprint: Oxford University Press
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Publish Date: 18-Dec-1986
Country of Publication: United Kingdom

Reviews

US Kirkus Review » Dworkin (Taking Rights Seriously) is one of the foremost legal theorists around, and his title for this collection of essays pinpoints his central theme. Dworkin does not believe that the legal system is apolitical - judges, he says, are always introducing political considerations into their rulings. Rather than decry this fact, Dworkin turns his attention to what principle ought to guide those decisions, and here he makes the case that the guiding principle ought to be a liberal one. Liberalism, he argues, is based on the principle of individual rights at the expense of some overriding conception of the public good. Judges ought not to decide in terms of a conceivable benefit to the community as a whole, or a significant fragment of it. Instead, they ought to hew to the fundamental fights of individuals, whether or not such rights happen to dovetail with the welfare of the community at any particular point (even, indeed, if assertion of an individual right would be detrimental to the welfare of the community). In Dworkin's own language, he makes a case for political principle over political policy. This argument rests on the theory that a government can treat its citizens as equals by allowing each of them to define what is of value to them, not by applying a single conception of the good life to everyone. Dworkin uses that theory to support specific legal rulings in several of the essays here: two focus on the Bakke case, and argue in favor of affirmative action programs (the individual rights of racial minorities take precedence here, while Bakke had no claim to a violation of individual fight); another essay argues against anti-pornography statutes on the basis of a right to sexual preference; yet another takes issue with the Snepp ruling, arguing for the primacy of First Amendment rights. These are difficult issues, but Dworkin has the gift of clarity - and even if he nowhere gives a convincing account of just what a right is and how it comes to be, he does illuminate the American legal tradition and its guiding principles. (Kirkus Reviews)


» Have you read this book? We'd like to know what you think about it - write a review about Matter of Principle book by Ronald M. Dworkin and you'll earn 50c in Boomerang Bucks loyalty dollars (you must be a member - it's free to sign up!)

Write Review


Books By Author Ronald M. Dworkin

Religion without God by Ronald M. Dworkin

Religion without God

Hardback, October 2013
$30.61
Taking Rights Seriously by Ronald M. Dworkin

Taking Rights Seriously

Paperback, April 2013
$29.69
Justice for Hedgehogs by Ronald M. Dworkin

Justice for Hedgehogs

Paperback, February 2013
$46.79
Is Democracy Possible Here? by Ronald M. Dworkin

Is Democracy Possible Here?

Paperback, July 2008
$44.26