1300 36 33 32

The reader is invited to follow a route that visits Fish's view of theory and practice,Raz's legal reasoning thesis, theoretical models of judicial review, Dworkin's right answer thesis, the law of the excluded middle and Lukasiewicz's development of three-valued logic, Wittgenstein's language games, and Moore's metaphysical realism. The destination is the practice at the heart of legal reasoning. It is suggested that this manifests the way in which the limitations of language and the incompleteness of human experience allow the opportunity for coherent development of the law and at the same time produce an inherent incoherence within the law. The central part of the book seeks to demonstrate how the problems of understanding legal reasoning replicate difficulties encountered in the philosophy of language, but challenges the attempts that have been made to harness approaches from within that discipline to illuminate legal reasoning. Instead it is argued that law provides an unrivalled test-bed for examining the limits of the capacity of our words, and that the study of law may be used to confront in a robust and illuminating manner the limitations of that discipline. The final chapter considers some of the implications of recognising the incoherence at the heart of legal reasoning, commenting on an institutional approach to law, the legitimacy of law, legal definitions, different approaches to legal reasoning, the role of appellate courts, the general possibility of providing a theoretical model of law, the use of legal rules, and the nature of law's critical aperture. The book should be of interest to advanced undergraduate students (particularly on jurisprudence courses), postgraduate students, academics, and practitioners concerned to reflect on the nature of the discipline they practice.

Buy Reasoning with Law book by Andrew Halpin from Australia's Online Bookstore, Boomerang Books.

Book Details

ISBN: 9781841130705
ISBN-10: 1841130702
Format: Hardback
(234mm x 156mm x 16mm)
Pages: 202
Imprint: Hart Publishing
Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing PLC
Publish Date: 12-Dec-2001
Country of Publication: United Kingdom

Other Editions

Reviews

» Have you read this book? We'd like to know what you think about it - write a review about Reasoning with Law book by Andrew Halpin and you'll earn 50c in Boomerang Bucks loyalty dollars (you must be a member - it's free to sign up!)

Write Review


Author Biography - Andrew Halpin

Andrew Halpin is Professor of Legal Theory in the School of Law at Swansea University.

Books By Author Andrew Halpin

Theorising the Global Legal Order by Andrew Halpin

Theorising the Global Legal Order

Paperback, September 2009
$73.80
Definition in the Criminal Law by Andrew Halpin

Definition in the Criminal Law

Hardback, October 2004
$68.40
Reasoning with Law by Andrew Halpin

Reasoning with Law

Paperback, December 2001
$67.50
Rights and Law by Andrew Halpin

Rights and Law

Paperback, July 1997
$71.99